The real emotional gut-punch comes in Season 2, Episode 6. The family has a “Christmas without Susannah” flashback. Conrad finds a recording of her singing. It’s so raw, it feels like someone is squeezing your heart like a stress ball. You are not okay.
Does Susannah die in The Summer I Turned Pretty? | TV & Radio | Showbiz
This is the moment you realize: she’s not coming back. No sequel. No dream sequence magic. Just a voicemail in a cold house.
How to Survive Watching It
First, stock your snacks. Get the good stuff—the ice cream you hide from your roommate. Second, watch with a friend who gets it. Someone who won’t judge you for sobbing into a throw pillow. And third, know it’s okay to pause and stare at a wall for ten minutes.
It’s also okay to remember that Susannah’s spirit lives on in the chaos. In the brownies Belly eats by the pool. In the way Jeremiah laughs. In Conrad’s brooding—which is honestly a tribute all its own.
